Why Is National Police Commissioner Still Suspended?
The National Police Commissioner, General Fannie Masemola, has been kept away from his office even after the criminal case against him was dropped. This has raised questions from political leaders and the public about what legal reason, if any, still justifies his suspension.
Charges withdrawn, but suspension remains
The case against Masemola involved alleged breaches of the Public Finance Management Act linked to the SAPS Medicare24 tender. After a review, the National Director of Public Prosecutions, Advocate Andy Mothibi, concluded there were no reasonable prospects of a successful prosecution. The Pretoria Magistrates’ Court formally withdrew the charges on 22 September 2026.
With the criminal case gone, many expected Masemola to return to his duties. Instead, the Presidency has said the matter remains “under consideration,” leaving the commissioner on leave.
ATM Leader Vuyo Zungula’s Questions
Vuyo Zungula, leader of the African Transformation Movement (ATM), wrote a letter to President Cyril Ramaphosa asking for clarity. He pointed out that if the suspension was based solely on the criminal charges, there appears to be no legal basis left for keeping Masemola out of office.
What Zungula wants to know
- Whether any disciplinary, administrative, or security process is still ongoing.
- What specific matters remain “under consideration.”
- When a final decision on Masemola’s status will be made.
- Whether the obligation to answer to Parliament is being used as a reason to keep him suspended, and if so, what law supports that.
Zungula stressed that his questions are not meant to shield Masemola from accountability. He believes any legitimate concerns about the SAPS procurement process should be dealt with through proper channels, not by leaving a senior official indefinitely suspended.
MK Party Calls for Immediate Reinstatement
The MK Party has also urged the President to lift the suspension. Spokesperson Sifiso Mahlangu said the criminal proceedings have collapsed, all charges have been withdrawn, and there is no lawful or rational basis for keeping Masemola away from his post. The party asked that the suspension be terminated “as soon as practically possible, preferably within the next 24 hours.”
Why This Matters for South Africa
Police leadership is crucial at a time when the country faces organised crime, corruption, political killings, and broader public‑safety challenges. Uncertainty at the top of the South African Police Service can affect morale, operational effectiveness, and public trust.
Both Zungula and the MK Party argue that a clear, transparent decision is needed—not only to uphold the rule of law but also to ensure that the police force can function effectively without lingering doubts about its leadership.
Conclusion
The withdrawal of criminal charges against General Fannie Masemola has left a legal vacuum regarding his continued suspension. Leaders from the ATM and the MK Party are demanding that the Presidency explain what, if any, legitimate basis remains for keeping the national commissioner out of office. Until a substantive answer is given, the situation raises concerns about accountability, due process, and the stability of South Africa’s police leadership.
