Case Overview
The Pretoria Magistrates Court has decided not to grant bail to three men accused of killing a 23‑year‑old email driver. The state says the crime was planned in advance and involved robbery with aggravating circumstances.
Who Are the Accused?
- Goitsione Machidi – 25 years old
- McClaren Mushwana – 30 years old
- Thabang Kenneth Mothwa – 27 years old
Three other suspects—Dikeledi Tears Mphela (24), Tumishang Mogau Mabutla (23), and Ofentse Senwamadi (18)—were also charged but had already withdrawn their bail requests.
What Happened on February 11, 2026?
According to the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), the six defendants allegedly worked together to:
- Attack and kill the email driver in Atteridgeville
- Steal his mobile phone and his vehicle
Police arrested all six suspects later that month after investigating the incident.
Court’s Decision on Bail
Machidi, Mushwana, and Mothwa later renewed their bail applications, arguing that the state’s evidence was weak. Prosecutor Chris Maruma opposed the requests, saying:
- The charges are very serious (premeditated murder and robbery)
- Releasing the men could disturb public peace
- It could damage trust in the justice system
The judge also noted that Mothwa already faces a separate case in Cullinan Magistrates’ Court for possessing a stolen vehicle, for which he had previously been granted bail.
Why Bail Was Denied
The court ruled that:
- The prosecution presented a strong prima facie case (enough evidence to proceed).
- The defendants did not show any exceptional circumstances that would justify their release.
Because of these points, bail was refused and the case was postponed to September 1, 2026 for further investigation.
What Happens Next?
The accused will remain in custody while investigators gather more evidence. The next court date in September will allow both sides to prepare for trial.
Conclusion
The Pretoria Magistrates Court’s decision reflects the seriousness of the allegations against the three men. By denying bail, the court aims to protect the community and ensure the legal process can continue without risk of interference or public concern. The case will now move forward, with a trial expected later this year.
