Background of the Case
In May 2020 three people were shot dead in the Hammarsdale township of KwaZulu‑Natal. The victims were Thamsanqa Gcabashe, who had just been elected secretary of the ANC Youth League, Lindokuhle Madonsela, a Durban Metropolitan Police officer, and Ndumiso Thosei, also a police officer. Five men—Fana Shabalala, Thulani Shozi, Zamokuhle Mnyandu, Sandile Msezane and Ntando Blose—are accused of carrying out the killings.
What the State Says Happened
According to the prosecution, the defendants were first hired to kill Madonsela. On 25 May 2020 they went to Gcabashe’s house by mistake and shot him instead. After realizing the error, they allegedly planned to kill Madonsela. A week later, on 9 June 2020, Thosei arrived in a silver Kia Rio to pick up Madonsela for work. While they were inside the car, a Toyota Etios pulled up alongside them and its occupants opened fire, fatally wounding Both Thosei and Madonsela.
Legal Representation Issue
Lawyer Withdraws
During a pre‑trial hearing earlier this week, advocate X Ntshulwana told the judge that he could no longer represent Thulani Shozi because he had run out of funds to continue the case.
Judge’s Response
Judge President Thoba Poyo‑Dlwati approved the withdrawal but stressed that the case has been dragging on for too long. She said:
“The incident occurred in 2020 and it is now 2026. This matter must be concluded.”
The judge ordered Shozi to explain how he would get a new lawyer and gave him a deadline to report back.
What Happens Next?
Shozi said Ntshulwana would stay on as a temporary advisor while he talks with his family about getting a new attorney. The judge, however, made it clear that Shozi must have proper legal representation by the next pre‑trial conference, which is set for 23 July. If he does not secure a lawyer by then, he will have to apply for legal aid.
The judge also directed Shozi to return to court before 23 July to confirm whether he has found a lawyer; otherwise, the court will consider a legal‑aid application.
Why This Matters
The case has attracted public attention because it involves both political figures (ANC Youth League secretary) and police officers. Delays in the trial can affect public trust in the justice system and prolong the pain for the victims’ families. Ensuring that each defendant has a lawyer is a basic right, and the judge’s firm timeline aims to keep the process moving forward.
Conclusion
The Durban High Court is pushing to resolve a murder case that has lingered for six years. After a lawyer withdrew due to lack of funds, the judge warned the accused that they must secure legal representation soon or face a legal‑aid application. The next court date on 23 July will show whether the defendants have arranged counsel and if the trial can finally proceed toward a conclusion.
